Skip to content

The best controller for your console

We read free tests from magazines and sites like Nintendo Life, Engadget and CGMagazine and add up their scores. The price is today's lowest.

Prices checked 19 November at 20:24.

The Pig's three picks

All controllers with tests

  1. Place 1:
    Nintendo Switch 2 Pro ControllerSwitch 2 · 7 variantsTest score 4.5 out of 5 · 6 tests(Nintendo Life, Engadget, Gaming Trend, How-To Geek, CGMagazine, XDA Developers)Reviewers find it comfortable, with smooth sticks and stronger vibration, but it lacks Hall effect sticks and analogue triggers (6 sources).
    • Slimmer grips that sit more comfortably in the hand (Nintendo Life)
    • Smooth sticks and buttons with clear feedback (Engadget)
    • New back buttons that can be mapped to any function (Nintendo Life)
    • What you give up: The sticks aren't Hall effect, and ZL and ZR aren't analogue. (Engadget)
    from SEK 851 at CS Megastore · Compare 7 shops
  2. Place 2:
    8BitDo Ultimate 2CSwitch · Switch 2 · PC · 5 variantsTest score 4.1 out of 5 · 2 tests(Nintendo Life, Engadget)Reviewers find it comfortable with Hall-effect sticks that shouldn't drift, but it can't wake the Switch 2 and has no NFC (2 sources).
    • Very comfortable to hold (Nintendo Life)
    • Hall-effect sticks with a lifetime no-drift guarantee (Engadget)
    • About 15 hours of battery life (Nintendo Life)
    • What you give up: It can't wake the Switch 2, has no NFC, and the casing feels fairly fragile. (Engadget, Nintendo Life)
    from SEK 229 at Proshop · Compare 3 shops
  3. Place 3:
    Victrix Pro BFG Reloaded (PS5)PS5 · PC · 4 variantsTest score 4.0 out of 5 · 2 tests(CGMagazine, TheSixthAxis)Reviewers like the Hall effect sticks and how much can be swapped and customised, but on PS5 it lacks haptics and gyro (2 sources).
    • Hall effect sticks the reviewer finds excellent (TheSixthAxis)
    • Swappable fight pad module for fighting games (CGMagazine)
    • A lot to customise (TheSixthAxis)
    • What you give up: No haptics and no gyro on PS5, and the triggers feel light. (CGMagazine, TheSixthAxis)
    from SEK 1,790 at Elgiganten · Compare 4 shops
  4. Place 4:
    8BitDo Ultimate 2Switch 2 · Switch · PC · 8 variantsTest score 3.9 out of 5 · 4 tests(Nintendo Life, CGMagazine, How-To Geek, TheSixthAxis)Reviewers find it feels premium and has very smooth sticks, but it can't wake the console (4 sources).
    • Feels premium (Nintendo Life)
    • TMR sticks the reviewer calls the smoothest around (Nintendo Life)
    • What you give up: It can't wake the Switch 2, so you have to turn the console on by hand. (Nintendo Life)
    from SEK 444 at Proshop · Compare 5 shops
  5. Place 5:
    Nacon Revolution 5 ProPS5 · PS4 · PC · 6 variantsTest score 3.8 out of 5 · 2 tests(TheSixthAxis, CGMagazine)Reviews praise the comfort and the Hall effect sticks, but it doesn't vibrate in PS5 games (2 sources).
    • Very comfortable shape and nice materials (TheSixthAxis)
    • Hall effect sticks designed to prevent stick drift (CGMagazine)
    • Plenty to adjust, both on the controller and in the app (TheSixthAxis)
    • What you give up: No rumble in PS5 games, and it can't turn on the console. (TheSixthAxis)
    from SEK 1,790 at Inet · Compare 2 shops

Tested, but not enough for a score

These have fewer than two scored tests from the last three years. We show the tests but give no test score.

The Pig answers

Good to know about controllers

Does a controller work with several consoles?

Sometimes. Many controllers are made for one console, and some also work with a computer. Check which consoles the maker names before you buy.

Wireless or wired?

A wireless controller gives you freedom on the sofa but needs charging or new batteries. A wired one never needs charging, but you are tied to the console or computer.

What is the test score?

It is the average of the scores the magazines' tests gave the controller, converted to a scale from 0 to 5. A controller gets a test score only once at least two tests from the last three years exist.

About the list

The test score is the average of the scores the magazines' tests gave, converted to a scale from 0 to 5. We only count free tests of that exact model, at most three years old, and give a test score only once at least two tests exist. Best overall has the highest test score. Best value gives the most test score per krona among those with at least 3.5. Cheapest that's good enough is the cheapest with at least 3.0. Colours and editions of the same model count as one, and we show the page most shops sell it on. No shop can buy a place, and what shops pay us never affects the order. How we rank (in Swedish)

Sources: Nintendo Life, Engadget, Gaming Trend, How-To Geek, CGMagazine, XDA Developers, TheSixthAxis, PCGamesN, Pocket-lint, Wccftech.